Table of content
- How to use this matrix
- Damage mechanism → NDT method matrix
- When routine NDT doesn’t apply
- NDT method hubs
- Key takeaways
- FAQs
- References
- Further reading
How to use this matrix
API 571, “Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining Industry,” catalogs the mechanisms that cause refinery and petrochemical fixed equipment — vessels, piping, tanks — to fail, grouped into five categories: mechanical/metallurgical failure mechanisms, uniform or localized loss of thickness, high-temperature corrosion, environment-assisted cracking, and other mechanisms. API 571 is currently in its Second Edition (published March 31, 2020), superseding an April 2011 First Edition. Knowing which mechanism you’re looking for only helps if you also know which NDT method can actually find it — and, just as importantly, which methods can’t.
The table below maps common damage mechanisms to the NDT methods typically used to detect them, with the equipment they usually affect and the key limitation of each method for that specific mechanism. It’s a quick-reference tool for integrity engineers scoping an inspection, not a replacement for API 571 itself or for the equipment-specific guidance in a plant’s own inspection procedures. For how these mechanisms fit into certification requirements and risk-based inspection scheduling, see the companion Asset Integrity Inspection: API 510, 570, 653 and RBI guide.
Damage mechanism → NDT method matrix
Damage mechanism | Typical equipment | NDT method(s) used | Key detection limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
Corrosion under insulation (CUI) | Insulated carbon/low-alloy steel piping and vessels, cold service, deadlegs | Pulsed eddy current (PEC); guided-wave UT (GWUT) for long runs; real-time digital radiography | PEC is semi-quantitative only; GWUT signal is attenuated by lossy insulation and general corrosion, and welds/bends/branches cause reflections that limit results; RT on-stream detects defects only down to ~0.25 in. diameter × 0.05 in. deep |
Sulfidation / sulfidic corrosion | Crude, FCC, coker, vacuum, visbreaker, hydroprocessing units; sour-gas-fired heaters | Automated UT; pulsed eddy current; guided-wave UT; real-time radiography/fluoroscopy (industry practice) | Automated UT limited to small areas per scan; PEC is qualitative only and limited to carbon/low-alloy steel; GWUT needs some insulation removal |
Hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) / blistering / SOHIC | Pressure/storage vessels, separators, absorbers, scrubbers, heat exchangers in wet H₂S service | Wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing (WFMT) — the most common method for this damage; phased-array UT (PAUT) as the alternative for cracked piping and other components WFMT can’t reach | WFMT finds subsurface HIC/SOHIC/SSC but, like other surface methods, is limited by component geometry and access; PAUT is the documented fallback specifically where WFMT can’t be applied |
Amine stress corrosion cracking (SCC) | Amine contactors, absorbers, strippers, regenerators, accumulators | Wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing (WFMT), eddy current (EC), RT, or ACFM; acoustic emission testing (AET) for crack-growth monitoring | Penetrant testing (PT) is not effective for this mechanism |
Caustic SCC | Carbon/low-alloy/austenitic stainless steel in caustic service (H₂S/mercaptan removal, alkylation neutralization) | WFMT, EC, RT, or ACFM; AET for monitoring | PT is not effective, the same limitation as amine SCC |
Chloride SCC | 300-series stainless steel under chloride-bearing insulation, contaminated hydrotest water, deadlegs, bellows | Liquid penetrant testing (PT), per a documented case example | Only a single case example is available — treat PT as one method that has found this mechanism, not a complete recommended-method list |
Polythionic acid SCC (PASCC) | Sensitized 304/304H and 316/316H stainless steel, typically exposed during shutdowns | PT can find PASCC | Less-sensitized grades (321/347, 304L/316L) are far less susceptible, which affects where inspection effort should focus |
Creep damage | Furnace tubes, supports, hangers, dissimilar-metal welds, reformer nozzles | Automated UT backscatter attenuation; dimensional measurement (perfilometry, laser OD); replication plus destructive metallography/SEM for confirmation | Surface scale conditions can mimic creep signals on UT; early creep damage is only conclusively visible under SEM, so UT/RT/EC/dimensional checks are typically paired with destructive sampling |
Erosion / erosion-corrosion | Elbows, flash zones, thermowells, pumps, high-velocity or turbulent piping sections | UT thickness mapping; RT; phased-array UT with flexible/conformable probes for curved geometry | Rigid phased-array probes can’t adapt to elbow curvature changes; naphthenic acid corrosion — a related but distinct API 571 mechanism, not erosion-corrosion itself — is separately noted as difficult to find during external examinations |
Thermal fatigue | Startup/shutdown cycling points, hot/cold mix points, coke drum skirts | No specific NDT method is well-documented for this mechanism | Do not assume PT/MT/shear-wave UT apply by analogy to mechanical fatigue without separate confirmation from a subject-matter expert |
Mechanical fatigue | Coke drums, auxiliary boilers, PSA vessels, pump shafts | PT, MT, and shear-wave UT (SWUT) for cracks; visual testing for small-bore piping oscillation; vibration monitoring for shaft imbalance | Standard surface-vs-volumetric caveat applies: PT/MT catch only surface-breaking cracks |
High-temperature hydrogen attack (HTHA) | Hydrotreaters, heat exchangers, piping and welds/HAZ, especially non-PWHT’d welds, above ~400°F/205°C | Phased-array UT (PAUT); time-of-flight diffraction (TOFD); total focusing method (TFM); Advanced Ultrasonic Backscatter Technique (AUBT), documented in API RP 941 | HTHA defects are very small and are described as difficult to detect with conventional UT; AUBT’s velocity-ratio sub-technique has limited sensitivity and needs a uniform microstructure in the backscatter signal to work reliably, and near-through-wall damage is hard to resolve |
Methods described as “industry practice” above come from technical briefs published by NDT equipment vendors rather than from API 571’s own text, and should be read as documented current practice, not standard requirements. See References for exact sourcing per row.
When routine NDT doesn’t apply
Not every damage mechanism in API 571 can be caught by field NDT at all. Three are worth calling out specifically, because the honest answer is “inspection isn’t how you manage this one”:
- Brittle fracture: API 571-sourced guidance states that inspection is not normally used to mitigate this mechanism. Susceptible vessels are checked for pre-existing flaws, but prevention relies on material selection and controlling pressure/temperature during startup, shutdown, and hydrotest — not routine NDT screening.
- Temper embrittlement: normal inspection methods cannot detect it. Toughness testing is the only conclusive way to confirm it.
- Graphitization: damage is not visible by normal NDT. Metallographic examination of coupons cut from the equipment is the effective method — there is no field NDT substitute.
If your inspection program is relying on UT, RT, MT, or PT to catch any of these three, it won’t — the controls that actually matter are upstream, in material selection and operating-limit discipline.
NDT method hubs
For a full explanation of how each method works, its equipment, and its general strengths and limitations beyond this matrix’s damage-mechanism focus, see OneStopNDT’s method guides:
- Ultrasonic Testing (UT)
- Radiographic Testing (RT)
- Magnetic Particle Testing (MT)
- Liquid Penetrant Testing (PT)
- Eddy Current Testing (ECT)
- Acoustic Emission Testing (AE)
- Guided Wave Ultrasonic Testing (GWUT)
Visual Testing (VT) doesn’t currently have a general-purpose method hub on OneStopNDT — only a welding-focused visual-inspection article exists.
Key takeaways
- No single NDT method catches every damage mechanism — and for three mechanisms (brittle fracture, temper embrittlement, graphitization), routine field NDT doesn’t apply at all; material selection and operating-limit control are the real safeguards.
- Penetrant testing is a genuine outlier within stress-corrosion cracking: ineffective for amine and caustic SCC, but a documented/implied method for polythionic acid SCC and chloride SCC — don’t apply a single “PT works for SCC” rule across all SCC types.
- Guided-wave UT’s main value is screening long, insulated, or inaccessible piping runs from a single access point — but its signal degrades with lossy insulation, general corrosion, and pipe geometry features like welds and bends.
- A few mechanisms in this matrix (thermal fatigue’s method mapping, chloride SCC’s full method list) have thinner published sourcing than the rest — treat those rows as a starting point to confirm with a subject-matter expert, not a complete answer.
- This matrix stays at the mechanism-to-method level; for how these mechanisms interact with certification requirements (API 510/570/653) and risk-based inspection scheduling, see the companion Asset Integrity Inspection guide.
FAQs
Can one NDT method cover all the damage mechanisms in API 571? No. Different mechanisms require different methods — surface methods (PT, MT) for surface-breaking cracking, volumetric methods (UT, RT) for subsurface and wall-loss damage, and for a few mechanisms (brittle fracture, temper embrittlement, graphitization), no routine field NDT method applies at all.
Why is penetrant testing effective for some SCC types but not others? PT is explicitly ineffective for amine and caustic SCC, while it’s the documented method for polythionic acid SCC and was used in a cited chloride-SCC case. This isn’t a general PT limitation — it’s specific to how each cracking mechanism presents at the surface, and is worth confirming with a materials engineer for your specific service.
What’s the difference between this matrix and API 571 itself? API 571 catalogs the damage mechanisms in detail — what causes them, what affects them, where they occur — but doesn’t always prescribe NDT methods in operational detail. This matrix supplements API 571 with sourced, current industry practice for detection, and flags clearly where that supplementary sourcing comes from a vendor technical brief rather than the standard itself.
Does this matrix replace a plant’s own inspection procedures? No. It’s a quick-reference starting point for scoping an inspection, not a substitute for equipment-specific procedures, a plant’s RBI program, or sign-off from a qualified inspector.
Where can I learn more about how a specific NDT method works? See the method-hub links above for UT, RT, MT, PT, ECT, AE, and GWUT. A general VT hub doesn’t currently exist on OneStopNDT — see the note above.
References
- API, “Damage Mechanisms Affecting Fixed Equipment in the Refining Industry” standards page (api.org/products-and-services/standards/important-standards-announcements/recommendedpractice571) — Second Edition, published March 31, 2020, superseding an April 2011 First Edition.
- TÜV Rheinland technical whitepaper, “NDT for Corrosion Under Insulation” — PEC, GWUT, and real-time digital radiography detection limits for CUI.
- Mistras Group, Sulfidation Corrosion application brief — NDT methods for sulfidic corrosion.
- Inspectioneering, API-571-based Damage Mechanism reference (inspectioneering.com/feature/mipi/dm/) — mechanism descriptions and NDT methods for HIC/SOHIC, creep, thermal/mechanical fatigue, brittle fracture, temper embrittlement, and graphitization.
- Inspectioneering, Environment-Assisted Cracking reference (inspectioneering.com/feature/mipi/dm/7) — amine SCC, caustic SCC, chloride SCC, and polythionic acid SCC mechanism and method details, including the PT-ineffective-for-amine/caustic-SCC finding.
- Inspenet, reformer-tube creep-damage inspection article, and Inspectioneering’s creep-damage reference — combined UT/dimensional/metallographic approach to creep detection.
- Olympus, FlexoFORM elbow-scanning case study (erosion-corrosion), and Inspectioneering’s erosion/erosion-corrosion reference.
- Eddyfi Technologies, HTHA detection technical literature, Inspectioneering’s AUBT/API RP 941 reference, and Inspectioneering’s HTHA damage-mechanism reference.
Further reading
- Asset Integrity Inspection: API 510, 570, 653 and RBI — how these damage mechanisms connect to certification requirements and risk-based inspection scheduling.
- Weld Inspection: Visual, Surface and Volumetric NDT — background on the surface and volumetric methods referenced throughout this matrix.
- NDT Certification Guide: ISO 9712, SNT-TC-1A and NAS 410 — for readers researching personnel certification for the methods listed here.
- CUI Detection Compared: PEC, Guided Wave, Profile RT, Thermography — a deep dive on detecting one of the damage mechanisms in this matrix.
- API 510, 570 and 653 Inspection Explained — plain-language explanation of the certification scopes behind this matrix.




There are no comments yet!