Table of content
- The principle that applies to every article below
- Article 2 — Radiographic Examination
- Article 4 — Ultrasonic Examination Methods for Welds
- Article 5 — Ultrasonic Examination Methods for Materials
- Article 6 — Liquid Penetrant Examination
- Article 7 — Magnetic Particle Examination
- Article 8 — Eddy Current Examination of Tubular Products
- Article 9 — Visual Examination
- Article 10 — Leak Testing
- Key takeaways
- FAQs
- References
- Further reading on OneStopNDT
The principle that applies to every article below
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section V, “Nondestructive Examination,” covers examination methods and techniques — how to perform radiography, ultrasonic testing, penetrant testing, and so on — not acceptance criteria. Acceptance standards (what counts as a rejectable flaw) live in whichever code references Section V for a given job: Section VIII for pressure vessels, Section I for boilers, B31.3 for process piping, or API 510/570/653 for in-service equipment. This single point applies to all eight articles covered here and is worth restating for every one of them, because it’s the most common point of confusion: Section V tells you how to look; the referencing code tells you what counts as a problem once you’ve found it.
Article 1, “General Requirements,” isn’t one of the eight articles in this series, but it sets the framework every numbered article sits under — procedures, personnel qualification, equipment calibration, and recordkeeping requirements that apply across the board. Each article below should be read alongside whatever Article 1 requirements the referencing code invokes.
Section V is currently on a 2025 edition cycle per standards-distributor listings; if your work is governed by a specific edition/addenda, confirm directly against the edition your referencing code calls out, since Section V’s own edition must match what the referencing code cites.
Article 2 — Radiographic Examination
Scope. Article 2 covers radiographic examination technique — radiation sources (X-ray and gamma), image quality indicators (IQIs), film density, geometric unsharpness, and viewing conditions.
What it doesn’t cover. Flaw acceptance limits. Those sit in the referencing code — for example, Section VIII Division 1 (UW-51/UW-52) for pressure vessels, or API 510 for in-service inspection.
Common mistakes:
- Confusing a light backscatter “B” image with a dark one — only a light B image requires a reshoot.
- Mixing up minimum film density requirements (1.8 for X-ray, 2.0 for gamma, both capped at a maximum of 4.0).
- Selecting IQI thickness based on base metal alone instead of base metal plus reinforcement plus any backing ring left in place during radiography.
- Placing a film-side IQI without the required lead “F” marker, or without the justification that placement requires.
Article 4 — Ultrasonic Examination Methods for Welds
Scope. Article 4 covers ultrasonic examination of welds. Like every article in Section V, it’s invoked only through a referencing code, which also supplies the acceptance criteria.
Mandatory appendix relationship. Mandatory Appendix V governs phased-array UT (PAUT) — encoded linear or sectorial scanning with phased-array probes, scan-plan requirements, distance-amplitude-correction (DAC) calibration, encoded scanning, and documentation. Acceptance tables live separately in the referencing code (for example, Section VIII Division 1 Mandatory Appendix 12, or B31.1/B31.3).
What it doesn’t cover. Acceptance criteria, as above — Article 4 governs technique, not pass/fail limits.
Common mistakes:
- Treating the 20% reference level (commonly set via DAC calibration) as an automatic rejection level, when it’s actually an investigate-and-evaluate threshold.
- Assuming one acceptance table applies universally, when different referencing codes set different tables.
- Exceeding the wedge-to-component contour limits for the probe/wedge combination in use.
- Using calibration blocks outside their valid diameter range.
- Scanning with increments too coarse, or without sufficient overlap, to reliably detect flaws.
- Recording processed or thresholded A-scan data instead of the raw data the procedure requires.
- Mistaking a geometric response (from weld cap, root, or component shape) for a real flaw indication.
- Incomplete documentation of probe, wedge, focal-law, and instrument settings.
Article 5 — Ultrasonic Examination Methods for Materials
Scope. Article 5 covers ultrasonic examination of materials — plate, forgings, bar, castings — distinct from Article 4’s weld-specific coverage. This distinction (materials vs. welds) is the main thing to get right about Article 5: using it interchangeably with Article 4 is itself a common point of confusion.
What it doesn’t cover. Acceptance criteria, as with every article in Section V — and, specifically, weld examination, which is Article 4’s territory.
Article 6 — Liquid Penetrant Examination
Scope. Article 6 covers liquid penetrant testing (PT) for surface-breaking discontinuities in nonporous materials, following the standard sequence: pre-clean, apply penetrant, remove excess, apply developer, examine/interpret, post-clean.
Key requirements. A written procedure is standard practice for Code-governed PT work, consistent with Article 1’s general requirements. For the solvent-removable (visible-dye) method, a minimum of 100 fc (1,000 lux) visible-light illumination is required, verified with a light meter. Penetrant dwell time follows the procedure or manufacturer’s instructions, and the penetrant must not dry during dwell. Indications should be evaluated at a defined point after development, since bleed-out patterns change with time. Work performed off the standard temperature range requires a demonstrated qualification.
What it doesn’t cover. Acceptance criteria — as with every article here, that lives in the referencing code.
Common mistakes:
- Skipping the written procedure on Code-governed PT work.
- Letting penetrant dry during dwell — a real failure mode requiring reclean/reprocess. Evaluating indications too late, since bleed-out patterns change with time, is also a risk.
- Measuring only the visible indication size, rather than recognizing it may not equal the true flaw size.
- Leaving residual contamination — rust, scale, paint, smeared metal — on the surface before testing.
- Incomplete penetrant removal, which causes false indications.
- Using PT on porous materials, where it isn’t applicable (porosity traps and bleeds penetrant).
- Skipping light-meter verification of illumination.
- Skipping required post-cleaning before welding — trapped penetrant can cause weld defects.
Article 7 — Magnetic Particle Examination
Scope. Article 7 covers magnetic particle testing (MT) for surface and near-surface flaws — ferromagnetic materials only. It doesn’t apply to austenitic stainless steel, aluminum, or copper-nickel alloys, where PT is used instead.
Key requirements. Examination requires magnetizing the part in two directions roughly 90° apart — a single pass is insufficient. Field strength is verified with a pie gauge, slotted shims, or a Hall-effect gaussmeter (30–60 Gauss). Yoke lifting power has minimums — at least 10 lb (4.5 kg) for AC yokes, at least 40 lb (18 kg) for DC yokes — verified annually, after repair, and daily in use. Wet fluorescent MT (WFMT) requires ambient light at or below 2 fc, at least 5 minutes of dark adaptation, UV-A intensity of at least 1,000 µW/cm² at 365 nm, and no photochromic eyewear. Where acceptance is specified, it’s typically per Section VIII Division 1 Appendix 6 — this is the referencing code’s job, not Article 7’s.
What it doesn’t cover. Acceptance criteria, and examination of non-ferromagnetic materials.
Common mistakes:
- Swapping the AC and DC yoke lift-power minimums.
- Confusing VT’s 100 fc lighting requirement with WFMT’s dark-adaptation requirement — these are opposite conditions for different methods.
- Single-pass magnetization instead of the required two-direction examination.
- Expecting MT to find deep subsurface flaws — DC fields only reach shallow depth.
- Treating Section V as the acceptance authority rather than the referencing code.
- Confusing the examiner’s role with the Authorized Inspector’s.
- Assuming subcontracting the examination removes the owner/user’s responsibility for it.
Article 8 — Eddy Current Examination of Tubular Products
Scope. Article 8 covers eddy current (ET) examination of tubular products, consistent with the ASTM standards Section V’s Subsection B adopts for this method — ASTM E426 (electromagnetic/eddy-current examination of seamless and welded tubular products in austenitic stainless steel and similar alloys) and ASTM E309 (magnetic-saturation eddy current for ferromagnetic tubing).
What it doesn’t cover. Acceptance criteria, as with every article here.
Article 9 — Visual Examination
Scope. Article 9 covers both direct and remote visual examination (VT). For direct viewing: the eye must be within 24 in. (600 mm) of the surface, at a viewing angle of at least 30°, with illumination of at least 100 fc (1,000 lux), verified by a calibrated meter. For remote VT, the system must resolve a 1/32 in. black line on an 18% gray card under equivalent conditions. Mirrors, magnifiers, and weld gauges are permitted as aids.
What it doesn’t cover. Acceptance criteria, as with every article here.
Common mistake: confusing VT’s 100 fc lighting requirement with WFMT’s dark-adaptation requirement — the same confusion flagged under Article 7, since the two methods sit at opposite ends of the lighting spectrum.
Article 10 — Leak Testing
Scope. Article 10 covers detecting and locating leakage paths through joints, welds, and components — it is not a system strength test, and is distinct from the hydrostatic or pneumatic strength testing required under codes like B31.3.
Appendix relationship. The bubble test sits under two mandatory appendices: Mandatory Appendix I (direct pressure) and Mandatory Appendix II (vacuum box). Pressure-change (decay) testing and tracer-gas methods (halogen diode detector, helium mass spectrometer) are named in secondary sources as well.
Relative sensitivity (general reference, not Article-10-specific): bubble testing offers lower-to-moderate sensitivity with good leak localization; pressure/vacuum decay testing is volume- and time-dependent; halogen/tracer-gas sniffing is moderate-to-high sensitivity; helium mass spectrometry is the most sensitive of the group.
What it doesn’t cover. A passing bubble or leak test does not substitute for a required system strength test under API 570 or B31.3 — conflating “pressure testing” with “leak testing” is a documented mistake.
Common mistakes:
- Judging acceptance by bubble size rather than the procedure’s stated leak-rate criterion.
- Using unapproved or uncalibrated bubble solutions, including household soap.
- Exceeding the maximum allowable working pressure (MAWP) of the weakest component in the system during the test — including temporary test blinds or clamps.
- Wrongly dismissing a continuous bubble stream as a false indication; only a single, non-repeating bubble may reasonably be treated that way, after ruling out trapped air or porous paint as the cause.
- Skipping or under-repeating required calibration.
- Incomplete records — procedure revision, calibration reference, examiner qualification, test parameters.
- For tracer-gas/mass-spectrometer methods: ignoring temperature effects, sniffing too fast or at the wrong standoff distance, helium background contamination, or a dirty vacuum system.
- Choosing a tracer gas without checking which gases are permitted for the application.
- Signing off a pre-startup safety review (PSSR) without understanding what the leak test actually confirmed.
Key takeaways
- Every article in Section V covers examination method and technique — none of them set acceptance criteria. Acceptance always comes from whichever code references Section V for a given job.
- Article 4 (UT, welds) and Article 5 (UT, materials) are easy to conflate but cover different things — welds versus base materials — and Article 8’s eddy-current scope is specifically for tubular products, not a general ET article.
- The clearest, best-sourced common mistakes in this series involve misreading a threshold as a rejection limit (Article 4’s 20% DAC level) or confusing two methods’ opposite lighting requirements (Article 7/9’s WFMT darkness vs. VT’s 100 fc illumination).
FAQs
Does Section V tell me whether a flaw I found is acceptable? No. Section V governs how you examine; the referencing code (Section VIII, Section I, B31.3, API 510/570/653, etc.) sets what counts as acceptable once you’ve found something.
What’s the difference between Article 4 and Article 5? Article 4 covers ultrasonic examination of welds. Article 5 covers ultrasonic examination of materials — plate, forgings, bar, castings — not welds. They’re easy to conflate but address different things.
Can I use Article 7 (magnetic particle testing) on stainless steel? Only on ferromagnetic materials. Austenitic stainless steel, aluminum, and copper-nickel alloys aren’t ferromagnetic, so Article 6 (penetrant testing) is used instead.
Does a passing leak test under Article 10 mean the system passed its strength test too? No — these are different tests. A leak test (Article 10) finds leakage paths; a strength test (hydrostatic or pneumatic, under the referencing piping code) confirms the system can hold pressure. Conflating the two is a documented, real-world mistake.
References
- littlepeng.com, “ASME Section V: Nondestructive Examination” — confirms Section V contains no acceptance standards; those live in the referencing code.
- Open Exam Prep, API 510 study guide, Articles 1, 6 & 7 — Article 1’s role as the general-requirements framework.
- Standards-distributor listings (AFNOR, SFS Finland) confirming a 2025 edition of ASME BPVC Section V exists.
- Open Exam Prep, RT Techniques & IQIs study guide — Article 2 scope, density/IQI requirements, common mistakes.
- Inspenet, “PAUT and ASME Section V Article 4” — Article 4 scope, Mandatory Appendix V, common mistakes.
- Sulzer technical procedure TP-0003 — Article 5 citations for instrument linearity and bolting calibration blocks.
- Open Exam Prep, Surface NDE (PT/MT/VT/Leak) study guide, Articles 1, 6 & 7 — Article 6 scope and common mistakes.
- National Board, penetrant testing reference — Article 6 sequence and requirements.
- Open Exam Prep, VT & MT per ASME V study guide (API 653) — Article 7 scope, requirements, common mistakes.
- ASTM E426 and ASTM E309 standard listings — the adopted ASTM standards consistent with Article 8’s stated scope.
- General (non-Section-V-specific) eddy current inspection discussion — cited only as informal background for Article 8, not as Article-8-specific guidance.
- Open Exam Prep, VT & MT per ASME V study guide (API 653) — Article 9 scope and requirements.
- Open Exam Prep, Leak Testing Article 10 study guide (API 570) — Article 10 scope and mandatory appendices.
- Open Exam Prep, ASNT NDT III Basic study guide, LT method — general sensitivity ranking across leak-testing methods.
- safteng.net, “Leak Testing per ASME Section V Article 10” — common mistakes and the pressure-test/leak-test distinction.
Further reading on OneStopNDT
- ASME Section V: Overview, Changes & Meaning — the existing parent overview page this series should link back to.
- NDT: Codes and Standards Overview — broader codes-and-standards context.
- Weld Inspection: Visual, Surface and Volumetric NDT — background on the methods covered in Articles 2, 4, 6, 7, and 9.
- NDT Certification Guide: ISO 9712, SNT-TC-1A and NAS 410 — for readers researching personnel certification for these methods.
- API 510, 570 and 653 Inspection Explained — examples of the referencing codes that set acceptance criteria for these articles




There are no comments yet!